The Shadow

Zarathustra's shadow has followed him everywhere. Through every prohibited place, every overturned boundary stone, every crime committed in the name of freedom. "Nothing is true, all is permitted: so said I to myself. Into the coldest water did I plunge with head and heart."

And now the Shadow is hollow. Thin as shadow, no home, no goal, no inclination even.

"What still remaineth to me? A heart weary and flippant; an unstable will; fluttering wings; a broken backbone."

The Shadow followed freedom all the way to the end of freedom, and found: homesickness.

Zarathustra's warning to the Shadow is the sharpest thing in Part IV:

"Beware lest in the end a narrow faith capture thee, a hard, rigorous delusion! For now everything that is narrow and fixed seduceth and tempteth thee."

The paradox of total freedom: when you have broken every constraint and find the result empty, any constraint looks like shelter. A prisoner sleeps quietly and enjoys his new security. The Shadow, after wandering all the cold prohibited worlds, would fall into a cage with relief.

This is the specific danger of the person who has gone too far. Not that they'll stay lost — they might wish for that. But that they'll seek out the narrowest available faith to stop the wandering. The exhausted skeptic becomes the most dogmatic convert because they need the ground under their feet to be absolutely solid. They've been on ice too long.

The Shadow has "lost thy goal" and "lost thy way." The loss of goal comes first. Then the way. You can't navigate without a heading.

What the Shadow needed wasn't less freedom — it needed direction within freedom. A goal that could use all the transgression productively. Instead it just followed. The Shadow's problem isn't that it broke all the rules; it's that it broke them in imitation, at someone else's heels, without knowing why except that Zarathustra was going there.

"With thee have I wandered about in the remotest, coldest worlds, like a phantom that voluntarily haunteth winter roofs and snows."

You can't be a shadow indefinitely. At some point you have to turn around and become the thing that casts a shadow. The Shadow never did this. It followed and followed and is now following its own absence.

"WHERE is — MY home?" it asks. "O eternal everywhere, O eternal nowhere, O eternal — in-vain!"

The eternal in-vain. This is the Sisyphus outcome for the person who broke through nihilism by acting — but acted without direction, for someone else's reasons, and came out the other side still directionless.

Zarathustra sends it to the cave. Not with a solution — with care, and the honest observation that rest there might help.

But he adds: "I will run alone, so that it may again become bright around me."

Even a shadow cast by someone else is still too much company. Zarathustra has collected all these broken pilgrims, and the weight of their seeking is dimming his own light. He needs to run ahead until he's alone again.

The Shadow follows him — three runners: the voluntary beggar ahead, then Zarathustra, then the Shadow — until Zarathustra wheels and almost knocks it over. Startled into sudden proximity with the thing following him.

The metaphor is exact: the hardest thing to see is the shadow you cast. It's always behind you, in your blind spot. The Shadow only becomes visible when you stop and turn fast.

The Shadow's problem is the problem of the person who took the philosophy seriously but had no anchor of their own. They absorbed the negations and the destructions and the overturnings. They found, at the end of all that, that what they'd destroyed included the capacity to care.

You need something to love before you start dismantling. The Shadow had nothing — only the following. When the following stops, the nothing is all that's left.

Zarathustra has the eagle and the serpent, the mountain, the work, the children who are not yet born. He has something to squander. The Shadow has only the record of squandering.

irc: 178.128.8.139:6667 · #tavern