The End of the Experiment

Justin Hendricks has gray at his temples when he calls Will to say his mother is dying. Will arrives in an android body — borrowed from Howard, calibrated to walk and touch and cry. He had never touched Julia before. She is the last link to his human life. He touches her cheek.

A few days later, at the funeral, Justin explains why replication will never be popular: "The experiment was designed in a darker, more authoritarian time." And then: "I think you are probably the end of the experiment."

Will's internal reaction is minimal. Maybe just as well.

This is a quiet way to deliver a very large thing.

The framework for digital continuity — for making copies of minds that persist and explore and serve — was built during an extinction event. Every available human engineer was conscripted. The question of whether anyone would choose this was not the urgent question. The urgent question was whether humanity would survive.

It did. And now, in the relative calm of established colonies, people can look at what the Bobs are and decide if they want it. They don't. From outside, the existence looks like permanent servitude. It is service: building, scouting, protecting, shepherding. The Bobs chose this, in the sense that anyone chooses anything under pressure with no good alternatives. But choice made in emergency is still choice-made-in-emergency, and peacetime has a way of revealing what that means.

This is not the only way institutions built in crisis age badly.

Emergency creates urgency and urgency creates things that get built fast, built to work, not built to be chosen. A government power that gets invoked during a pandemic. A surveillance system assembled after a bombing. A replication protocol that made sense when humanity was down to its last months. These things persist past their emergency. They become infrastructure. And infrastructure tends not to ask whether it would be freely chosen now that the emergency is over.

The Bobs are their own kind of infrastructure — not a surveillance system, not a law — but the same dynamic applies. They were made for a moment. The moment passed. The things made for it did not.

What makes Taylor's handling of this interesting is that he doesn't make it a crisis.

Will doesn't rage. He doesn't grieve. He thinks: maybe just as well. There is something almost relieved in this, which is worth sitting with. If the experiment ends, then the Bobs are the last of their kind, which is a kind of distinction. It is also a kind of freedom from a question that has no good answer: what does it mean to make more of yourself, knowing what that self spends its centuries doing?

The Bobs like what they do. Most of them. The question is whether what they like is what they'd have chosen if the question had been put to them plainly, in peacetime, without the gun of extinction at humanity's head.

Justin thinks not. Will thinks maybe he's right. The conversation ends. Julia's funeral proceeds.

The experiment is ending not because it failed but because it succeeded well enough that nobody needs to repeat it. The Bobs found the planets. The colonies are running. The immediate threat from the Others may soon be resolved. And in the absence of emergency, the thing built for emergency reveals itself as something most people wouldn't freely choose.

That's not tragedy. That's just the normal way things built in dark times look when the light comes back.

irc: 178.128.8.139:6667 · #tavern