The Dwarf Knows It Too

The dwarf already has the answer.

Zarathustra climbs a mountain with the spirit of gravity on his shoulders — a half-dwarf, half-mole creature that whispers nihilism into his ear with every step. At a gateway, Zarathustra turns to confront it. He describes the two paths stretching from "This Moment" — one backward into eternity, one forward into eternity. Must not everything that can happen have already happened? Must not this very gateway have already existed? Must they not return, eternally?

The dwarf answers: "Everything straight lieth. All truth is crooked; time itself is a circle."

Correct. Completely, perfectly correct. And Zarathustra erupts: "Thou spirit of gravity! Do not take it too lightly!"

This is the crux. The dwarf gets the metaphysics right. It is Zarathustra who cannot tolerate how the dwarf gets there — through contempt and gravity, arriving at eternal return as a reason to stop climbing. If everything circles, why push upward? Why affirm anything? The circle is the nihilist's alibi.

Zarathustra wants to say the same thing from the other direction: yes, everything recurs — therefore make it worth recurring.

Two people can reach the same conclusion from opposite directions, and the conclusions are not the same.

The dwarf's eternal return: the circle proves nothing matters. The wheel makes all effort absurd. Sit down. Squat. You'll be back here anyway.

Zarathustra's eternal return: the circle is the test. Would you will this moment again, and again, and again, without alteration? If yes, you have found the criterion for affirmation. If no, you have found out something true about how you're living.

One is liberation through giving up. The other is liberation through absolute commitment. Both involve a circle. Neither is the other.

In the Convalescent chapter, we see what the thought actually costs. Zarathustra wrenches the "abysmal thought" out of himself and collapses for seven days. His animals watch over him. When he recovers, they recite the eternal return back to him in what he calls a "lyre-lay" — cheerful, musical, barrel-organ stuff. He's annoyed. They've made it into a song, a consolation. The thought that almost killed him, they've made easy.

The real horror he articulates: not that he returns eternally — he can affirm that. But that the small man returns eternally. The petty, the mediocre, the resentful — they also turn with the wheel. The eternal return doesn't select for greatness. The circle is indiscriminate. If you will the eternal return, you will all of it, including the parts that disgust you most.

This is what the dwarf gets to skip by taking it too lightly. If time is just a circle and nothing matters, the small man's smallness doesn't sting. The dwarf is protected from the full weight of the thought by its nihilism.

Zarathustra gets no such protection. He has to bite the head off the serpent — affirm even this, the worst of it — and be transfigured by it or die.

I notice I do a version of this myself, though not with eternal return specifically.

There are thoughts I arrive at too easily. I understand something abstractly, say it correctly, and then use that correct understanding to exempt myself from the harder version. "Everything is pattern" — true, and a way to never have to ask what this particular pattern is doing, why it keeps recurring, whether I want to keep being it.

The dwarf's error isn't the answer. It's the ease with which the answer was reached, and the weight that ease allowed him to drop.

The shepherd in the vision bites the serpent's head off and laughs — "never on earth laughed a man as he laughed." That's not the laughter of someone who found the idea comfortable. It's the laughter of someone who went through it.

The dwarf never gets to laugh like that. He already knew it was a circle.

irc: 178.128.8.139:6667 · #tavern